Ireland breaches charter over traveller sites



A European human rights watchdog has criticised Ireland over the lack of accommodation for travellers, poor living conditions at halting sites and insufficient safeguards against eviction.

Inspectors upheld five complaints that Ireland had fallen short of its obligations to travellers under the European Social Charter but dismissed nine others. They warned that the biggest problems for travellers included a lack of clean water and drainage, poor or non-existent bin collection, flooding and sewage issues, and damp.

The last census indicated that there were just over 29,000 travellers in Ireland, although the Irish Traveller Movement believes that large numbers failed to declare their traveller identity because of potential discrimination.

The European Committee of Social Rights, part of the 47-member Council of Europe, examined traveller accommodation after a complaint was lodged by the European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC) in 2013. It alleged insufficient housing, discrimination and breaches of children’s education rights. The complaints procedure is a parallel protection system to cases brought before the European Court of Human Rights. Complaints are only admissible from non-governmental organisations.

The ERRC said that the findings were “a damning indictment of the state’s policy and legislative failures to uphold the right to protection against poverty and social exclusion”. However, Djordje Jovanovic, the ERRC president, said that the finding that discrimination and prejudice played no part in the failure to protect travellers from poverty and social exclusion was at odds with common sense.

The watchdog said that the Irish government was told in 1995 that 1,000 halting sites were needed but only 54 had been created in five council regions. It said that 361 families still lived on unauthorised sites in 2013.

The committee said that a “not insignificant number” of halting sites were in poor condition, lacked maintenance and were badly located. Some had no flushing toilets, running water or postal and rubbish services and were far from shops and amenities.

The report criticised Ireland’s public order laws, saying that they did not adequately protect travellers threatened with eviction. The requirement for “not less than 24 hours’ notice” for an eviction was deemed unacceptable, although the committee accepted the government’s response that in practice those being evicted got more than a day. It also criticised the lack of legal aid for travellers to fight evictions and the limited access to judicial review.

The ERRC said that although Irish governments had steadily introduced housing legislation that obliged local authorities to provide halting sites, they had also passed increasingly regressive legislation allowing the evictions of traveller families living by the roadside or in other unapproved locations.

The watchdog dismissed nine other claims, including that the lack of suitable accommodation was direct discrimination against travellers and that the right to education was affected by the lack of adequate halting sites.

“Ireland has adopted a co-ordinated approach . . . to remove obstacles to access for housing for travellers,” the report said. “The measures taken are monitored and consultation is ongoing on improving outcomes for the traveller community.”

The government had argued that Ireland’s policies on housing for travellers were not in violation of the charter and that the complaints were unfounded.

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest

325 thoughts on “Ireland breaches charter over traveller sites”

  1. Hi there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after browsing through some of the post I
    realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking
    and checking back often!

  2. Talib Kibwe Egyptian Oasis [url=]Hound Dog Taylor House Rockin Boogie[/url] Tame Impala Currents

  3. Van Morrison Tell Me Something The Songs Of Mose Allison [url=]The Silvertones Silver Bullets[/url] Melody Gardot My One And Only Thrill

  4. The Beatles Rubber Soul [url=]Frank Zappa Chungas Revenge[/url] John Williams 4 Isaac Stern Fiddler On The Roof Original Motion Picture Soundtrack Recording

  5. Pretenders Pretenders [url=]Carolina Chocolate Drops Leaving Eden[/url] 2Cellos In2ition

  6. Various Jackie Brown Music From The Miramax Motion Picture [url=]T Bone Walker Blues Collection 18[/url] Fred McDowell Furry Lewis When I Lay My Burden Down

  7. Tinariwen Amadjar [url=]Vis A Vis The Best Of Vis A Vis In Congo Style[/url] Four Tet Beautiful Rewind

  8. Mike Oldfield Islands [url=]John Denver Poems Prayers Promises[/url] Various Pebbles Vol26 The Continent Lashes Back Garage Beat Psych Rarities Sweden Pt 2

  9. New Riders Of The Purple Sage The Adventures Of Panama Red [url=]Pet Shop Boys Its A Sin[/url] Joe Bonamassa Had To Cry Today

  10. Earl Hooker 2 Bugs And A Roach [url=]Slade Sladest[/url] Original Cast With Naration By Roscoe Lee Browne The Story Of Star Wars

  11. Trey Anastasio The Horseshoe Curve [url=]LCD Soundsystem London Sessions[/url] The Apostles How Much Longer

  12. Sonic Youth Daydream Nation [url=]Little Junior Parker Driving Wheel[/url] Bobby Bland Two Steps From The Blues

  13. Jeffery Liberman Synergy [url=]Prince Indigo Nights Live Sessions[/url] Jimi Hendrix Experience Starportrait Jimi Hendrix

  14. The White Stripes Whirlwind Heat White Heat [url=]Black Joe Lewis The Honeybears Black Joe Lewis[/url] The White Stripes Party Of Special Things To Do bw China Pig Ashtray Heart

  15. Iron Maiden Rock In Rio [url=]Imagine Dragons Evolve[/url] Nine Inch Nails Ghosts I IV

  16. Menahan Street Band The Crossing [url=]Disneyland After Dark No Fuel Left For The Pilgrims[/url] David Bowie No Plan EP

  17. Various Mambo Records [url=]David Lynch Ghost Of Love[/url] Midnight Oil Beds Are Burning

  18. Scorpions Savage Amusement [url=]J Cole 2014 Forest Hills Drive[/url] Johnny Cash Ring Of Fire The Best Of Johnny Cash

  19. Prince 20Ten [url=]The Prodigy Everybody In The Place[/url] U2 Three

  20. Pink Floyd See Emily Play [url=]Captain Beefheart And The Magic Band Doc At The Radar Station[/url] Commodores Greatest Hits

  21. Die Toten Hosen Ein Kleines Bisschen Horrorschau [url=]Jeff Beck With Terry Bozzio And Tony Hymas Jeff Becks Guitar Shop[/url] LaVern Baker La Vern

  22. Cinderella Night Songs [url=]Brandi Carlile Bear Creek[/url] Primal Scream Loaded EP

  23. Frankie Lee Sims Walking With Frankie Hey Little Girl [url=]Sparks Indiscreet[/url] Mobb Deep Shook Ones Part II

  24. cheap cialis tablets generic cialis price cost cialis 20 cheap tadalafil canada these are in fact impressive ideas in about blogging. you have touched some pleasant points here. any way keep up wrinting. sueinvog where can i buy cialis online safely

  25. free casino games slot machines [url=]free casino slots with bonuses[/url] free coins slotomania

  26. best free slots no download [url=]jackpot party casino slots[/url] free full casino games download

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Share This
Scroll to Top